Separating the personal from the political

On June 23, 1980, a young man entered the local office of an opposition party, where the local MLA was meeting with some party workers. With a jubilant look on his face, the young man announced that Sanjay Gandhi, son of then Prime Minister, Indira Gandhi, had died that morning when an aircraft flown by him crashed near Safdarjung Airport in New Delhi. Hearing this, some of the party workers started cheering.

The MLA immediately said in a raised voice, “Stop this! How can you people even think of cheering about somebody’s death? You should be ashamed of yourselves!”

After a few seconds of pin-drop silence, one party worker asked, “Sir, we all know about the atrocities that Sanjay Gandhi committed during the Emergency, which had been declared by his mother Indira Gandhi to protect her political interests. What is wrong in celebrating the death of such a person?”

The MLA, who had spent 18 months in jail in 1975-77 as a political prisoner during the Emergency, replied, “A young man has lost his life. An infant has lost his father. A young woman has lost her husband. An elderly mother has lost her son. This is a sad moment for everybody. As members of our party, we will continue to oppose Indira Gandhi politically. But, as human beings we must sympathise with her and her family.”

I remembered this incident when I read about Narendra Modi’s political opponents and others making all kinds of negative statements about his recent declaration about his marital status.

Narendra Modi’s political opponents and critics should continue to oppose him on political grounds. But it is not correct on their part to use his personal life as a stick to beat him with.

In my opinion, Narendra Modi is not to be blamed in this matter. His marriage was fixed and conducted by his parents when he was 17 years old. Hence, he has been the victim of the social ill called child marriage. We always sympathise with the victim of any social ill. So, why should we criticize this victim of a social ill?

Read more about this subject on Firstpost and Rediff.


8 thoughts on “Separating the personal from the political

  1. I completely agree. Politics must certainly be delinked from personal issues.
    Thank god nobody touched on ND Tiwari’s paternity issue. His ‘son’s’ persistence ultimately won the battle that the old man thought could be covered up!

  2. People always enjoy believing the worst of someone and rejoice in their misfortune. In politics they will grasp at any straw! Sad but true.

    Thank you for your kind comment on my blog today, Pro. 🙂

  3. Politics & personal attacks is the norm rather than the exception in India. Election time is the worst as all with no exception will talk on the personal level rather than their own capabilities. They forget that there is a certain decorum & ethics to follow, not only in politics but in every walk of life. But then again I guess the power of “The Chair” is all consuming.

  4. He looks likely to be India’s next PM — but I’m not sure his behavior and history inspire me.

    India is a thriving democracy, so I guess the will of the people will be done. I just wish we had more alternatives.

    • I am not commenting on Modi’s credentials for the PM’s position.
      My only point is: unless it has bearing on his/her role as a politician, a politician’s personal life should not be brought into political discussion.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s