Is our ‘Unity in diversity’ a myth?

Some years back, I shifted from Mumbai to another city on a transfer. I reached that city one evening and checked into a hotel. The next day, I visited the house arranged for me by my company to get it spruced up prior to my moving in.

I unlocked the gate and was walking towards the main door when I heard somebody call out, “Excuse me!” I turned around to see a middle-aged woman outside the neighbouring house. As I walked towards the hedge between the two houses, she asked, “Will you be living in this house?” As soon as I replied in the affirmative, she asked me, “Do you eat envy?”

I replied, “I’m sorry, Madam, I don’t understand your question.”

“Are you vegetarian or do you eat hens and goats and all that stuff?” she asked, her face expressing disgust. Then it struck me her original question was, “Do you eat NV?”

I decided to have some fun, so I replied, ““Madam, I eat and drink anything that’s edible.”

She was silent for a few seconds. Then, she asked, “But you look vegetarian. What’s your name?” When I told her my name, she smiled broadly and said, “Oh! That means you are an upper-caste person! So you are a pure vegetarian, thank God!”

I decided it was time to clarify things. I said, “Madam, I was born in an upper-caste family. But, I do not follow all the restrictions. As I said, I eat and drink anything that’s edible. However, let me assure you that you will not be disturbed in any way by my food habits or anything else. In future, if you face any inconvenience because of me, please tell me and I will take corrective action.”

A few days later, I moved into the house. This woman and her husband were extremely helpful people, but she kept making uncalled for remarks about ‘NV’, about ‘you Bombay people’, and about anything and everything about me that she found ‘different’. A few other people behaved similarly with me. But most people I came in contact with treated me as one of their own. In addition, I was a ‘resilient’ Bombay guy, educated and with a secure job. Hence, I could take these remarks in my stride, almost treating them as a joke, choosing to appreciate her helpful nature.

Imagine a person from the north east or any ‘underdeveloped’ state, perhaps a student or a person in search of a job, looking ‘different’, speaking with a ‘different’ accent, facing such remarks from many persons hostile to them. Such a person would feel totally alienated by such remarks.

I have seen how this happens all over our country. All of us feel bad when we are treated as ‘outsiders’ when we travel outside our ‘home state’. But in our own ‘home states’, many of us treat people from other states as ‘outsiders’. We poke fun at the accents/dress/customs/etc. of people from other states. But we feel bad when people from other states poke fun at our accents/dress/customs/etc… This fun is neither harmless nor good-natured. It is not limited to states. It applies to religions, castes, languages, etc., etc.. Yet, we boast about our nation’s ‘Unity in diversity’.

I think our ‘Unity in diversity’ is a big myth. We are genuinely united only when we are watching India playing international cricket matches. Otherwise, we are a divided lot.

Do you agree?

What should we do to achieve genuine ‘Unity in diversity’?


12 thoughts on “Is our ‘Unity in diversity’ a myth?

  1. I don’t think we have unity in diversity even during cricket matches that India plays against Pakistan for that matter. Apart from seeing this unity in diversity term in text books, I am yet to come across the same in real life in 34 yrs of my life in India.

  2. I certainly don’t think so. It’s a simple mindset.
    In the north everyone living in the south of the Vindhyas is termed a “Madrasi”. Conversely, for the ‘more learned’ southies, each one from the north is a “bhayya” whether s/he hails from MP, Bihar, UP, Rajasthan, Punjab or Haryana.
    The “bongs” from the east have a superiority complex of ‘what India is thinking today, Bengal has already thought yesterday”!
    Unfortunately, those from the NE fall between the stools and get a raw deal – it all began with Bengaluru and the virus spread to Delhi taking a more violent form. It badly needs to be corrected. Sooner the better.

  3. Big doses of tolerance, that’s what. People are always only too quick to find fault.

    That being said, on a lighter note, the fragrance of fish frying wafting into my kitchen doesn’t excite me at all 😀 as I am a vegetarian. But that does not mean I’ll do anything about it, because they have a right to their food choice.

    The thing is, people prefer to poke fun or sneer rather than accept diversity.

  4. In real life, there is nothing like Unity in Diversity. It was just a chapter we had in our social sciences book. Period. In my view, such remarks actually show the mentality of the person and in no way does it reflect the characteristics of the victim, his/her state, caste, religion or anything else. One has to grow up enough to understand the difference between a harmless joke and a racial/ethnic remark. Why does it hurt them when the tables are turned?

    Loved the ‘eating envy’ part. Must have been a funny moment. 😀

    • I have never forgotten that she asked me that question before even asking me my name!
      As I mentioned, she and her husband were extremely helpful people and became our good friends. But her remarks and taunts never stopped.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s