Are we born corrupt?

Last week, my guest expressed his desire to visit a renowned spiritual centre located just outside my city. My guest was particularly keen to attend one of their special meditation sessions, about which his colleague had spoken very highly.

We had tried unsuccessfully to obtain information over the phone. However, my guest’s colleague had told him that the special meditation session was held at 9.00 am every day, and that the ticket had to be booked in person the previous day. Hence, my guest and I left my house at 7.00 am on Saturday, hoping to reach the spiritual centre by 8.00 am. Our plan was to book tickets for the special meditation session on Sunday. There was also a possibility of obtaining entry into the Saturday session if there were ‘no-shows’.

We reached the spiritual centre at 8.00 am and proceeded to the office. The volunteer handling the bookings for the special meditation sessions informed us that the sessions on that day and the next day had both been fully booked, and that there were 20 persons on the official waiting list for each session. He suggested that we look around the place and meet him again at 9.00 am to check if, “by your good luck”, there were some vacancies by that time.

When we checked at 9.00 am, we could not gain entry. The volunteer suggested that we could come back at 8.30 am the next day to try our luck once again. I requested him to ‘somehow arrange’ at least one ticket for my guest who lives over 1,000 kilometers away. He smiled and replied, “It depends entirely on the Almighty. I can do nothing. Just hope and pray for the best.” He confirmed that tickets could be booked only in person, and a person could book a ticket only for himself/herself.

While my guest and I were disappointed, we were both thrilled that the entire process was clean. There was not even a hint or whiff of any corruption!

That evening, as we were window-shopping in the local mall, I met my neighbour. He was thrilled about the fact that he had managed to get a ticket for the next day’s special meditation session at the same spiritual centre. He just couldn’t stop talking about it. When he said that he had obtained the ticket that afternoon, my curiosity was aroused. On asking a few questions, I understood that his ticket had been arranged by an acquaintance and that the volunteer handling the bookings at that time was not the volunteer we had met. My guest and I realised that there may be some corruption involved in the ticketing process.

We reached the spiritual centre at 8.00 am the next day. The volunteer whom we had met the previous day was handling the bookings for the special meditation sessions. He asked us to meet him at 9.00 am. This time, instead of walking around, we waited there and kept our eyes and ears open. We saw that there were definitely some irregularities going on. Quite a few persons without tickets and who were not on the waiting list were being allowed to attend the special meditation session. The body language and gestures exchanged between some of the volunteers and some of the non-ticket, non-waitlist attendees definitely indicated some ‘give-and-take’.

At 9.00 am, the volunteer announced to all those waiting that the session was full up. We waited till the others had left. Then, my friend told the volunteer about what we had heard and seen. Initially, the volunteer denied any possibility of any irregularity, but when we persisted, he admitted that “it could be possible that something irregular may have happened”. He gave me his mobile number and assured me that he would arrange tickets for the special meditation sessions in future over telephone for me and my family members. I didn’t bother to ask him how he could arrange tickets over phone when he had stated the previous day that tickets could be booked only in person. Obviously, he was offering me a sop to make me keep quiet about what we had observed!

Malpractice in religious / spiritual places is not a new phenomenon. However, I was disappointed because this particular spiritual centre is spoken about very highly even by people who are not its devotees. From whatever we could see and hear, the devotees, volunteers and visitors are almost all educated, English-speaking persons who, as a class, pride themselves on being above corruption.

I cannot help asking myself:
Are we born corrupt?
Or do we achieve corruption?
Or is corruption thrust on us?

What’s your take?


8 thoughts on “Are we born corrupt?

    • I must state that I have come across instances of corruption in various religious organisations of many faiths.

      To the best of my knowledge, no religion supports or condones corruption. But that does not prevent religious persons from indulging in corruption.

      • I think you are right. Some religious organizations are built on corruption and bilk unsuspecting members out of their fortunes.

        I think the ubiquitous nature of corruption across mankind is strong evidence that this is a condition with us since birth–dormant at first, rampant at times, and always a struggle.

        This evidence refutes ideas that we are “perfect” or Divine.

  1. In response to your three questions, I can categorically say each holds good depending upon the circumstances that one is confronted with. There are many bribe givers and takers born that way. The second, seeing others doing it and become a part of the system – in some departments the centralized ‘collections’ are distributed in cash after the pay is dished out. The last, the reluctant ones are forced into parting with money as ‘speed money’ only to get over the nuisance value!

  2. No we are not born corrupt. We get carried away by ads like special meditation or special something and get desperate to get there. Many systems are rotten (i am hoping all are not) and there always are some people trying to exploit the excessive demand compared to supply. Everyone wants to get money without earning it. People want to get ahead without being patient or having to work the way through. We acquire this over a period of time, as we see people who cheat are getting ahead and not getting caught. Depending on your fundamentals, you will fall for it sooner or later, some very rare people may never fall. If you see your father driving through red signal when cop is not around, you will learn corruption sooner.

  3. I go for no.3 – corruption is thrust on us – and depending on the urgency in the situation, we succumb. Or not.

    Religion is extremely corrupt. When we can bribe God and get around rituals…..oh well. 🙂

  4. The corruption is thrust on us. We are from the land of ‘chai-paani ke liye kuch’ or ‘bachchon ki mithai ke liye kuch’. The first time I heard this, I wondered, does tea, coffee or sweets cost us in thousands. Only when I grew up I got to understand the real essence of this seemingly polite request. I was home yesterday to receive my daughter’s passport and the postman stood for over 20-25 minutes outside the gate expecting the ‘chai-paani’. I’m sure the next time I have a packet to be delivered home, it’s either gonna get delayed or lost. The best part is they take it as their right.

    As for corruption in religious places, I went all the way to Tirupati with my mother in 2002. There was an endless queue of devotees and the counter guy told us if we waited in the queue we’ll have to wait for at least 4-5 days for darshan. Then he offered us a photocopied slip which offered prices of various timelines for visit. If we had paid Rs.3000 per person, we would have been allowed darshan immediately. I refused to pay and told my mom that the Lord would have left the place long back. No wonder he is sitting there with his eyes closed. 🙂

  5. You know, till a few years ago, when choosing whom to vote, I would think ‘Everyone is corrupt, and you only have a choice in voting for the lesser evil’. I almost reached a point where I would justify corruption, by saying that their salaries are so less, what option do they have!?
    Our generation has seen it so much in our system, so commonly around us, that it seems ‘normal’ to us. It was not until Anna Hazare’s movement that we started questioning what all of our actions are corrupt. Whether paying a little extra to the maid part of payment of her services, or is that corruption?

    So, I would say’ We are born corrupt’.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s